Client portal sign-in

GIC versus GIC … What’s the difference? Time and money!

Business Matters, Wealth Management

Confused? You would not be the first person to mix up these two GIC investment vehicles: guaranteed investment certificates and guaranteed interest contracts. Although their acronym is the same, the differences between these GICs could have material implications for your money, especially when it comes to transferring wealth to the next generation. 

Individuals often find themselves holding a large portion of their wealth in non-registered investments. This may have been a result of an inheritance, shrewd saving, recent downsizing to a condo or the sale of a business. Whatever the scenario, the risk to the non-registered money if you pass away is that your estate and this money will be subject to probate – along with the delays and fees that come with it.

The perils of probate

Let’s first review this key concept: Probate is the legal process where a judge reviews the deceased’s will for validity and authenticity, and appoints the executor of the estate. It comes with a cost that is levied to the estate.

Each province has its own set of probate fees. For example, in Ontario on an estate worth $200,000, the probate costs would be about $2,250, or close to 1.1% of the estate’s value.

Moreover, in Ontario the probate process will delay the release of estate funds by six to nine months. In the meantime, while your estate’s funds are tied up in the courts, your surviving loved ones may be required to pay the cost for certain final expenses, such as funeral and burial costs, and the additional professional service fees that accompany the administration of the deceased’s estate, including accounting, legal and executor fees. In the end, for a $200,000 estate, these costs may subtract another $3,900: for a combined estate cost of $6,150, or close to 3% of your estate.

The GIC that protects more of your assets

So, why does this matter to your non-registered GIC portfolio? Well, if you would like to ensure a smooth, cost-effective transfer of your wealth to the next generation, then choosing the right type of GIC is important.

Although both bank and insurance GICs operate in much the same manner while an individual is alive, it is the treatment of the GICs within the estate that shows the important difference between the two.

If you hold an insurance GIC, it will help protect your non-registered assets from these influences, as you can elect a beneficiary to your insurance GIC that allows the non-registered assets to flow directly to them – and bypass probate. Holding a traditional bank GIC will expose your non-registered assets to the probate, potential delay and additional fees discussed above.

More information to help you plan

The table below expands on these similarities and differences between the two investment vehicles. Use this information as part of your overall investment planning, for a clearer picture that helps you make a more informed choice to fit your goals.

FactorsGuaranteed investment certificate(Bank GIC)Guaranteed interest contract(Insurance GIC)Comment
IssuerBankInsurance companyBank GIC is structured as a traditional savings vehicle, while the insurance GIC is set up as a standard insurance contract
Interest rateYesYesDifference is ~+15% in favour of Bank GIC
Term1 to 5 years1 to 10+ yearsMore maturity options are available for the insurance GIC
GuaranteeCanadian Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC) – up to $100,000Assuris – up to $100,000Different providers insure these investments, but they both offer similar coverage
Pension tax creditNoYesInsurance GIC income qualifies for the pension income tax credit
Legacy providedNoYesYou are able to designate a beneficiary for a non-registered Insurance GIC
Avoids probate / estate administrationNoYesMoney transfers directly to your beneficiary and avoids probate costs and public record of your estate disposition
Protected from creditorsNoYesInsurance GICs held in a non-registered account are protected from creditors (in most provinces)

This article is reprinted from the newsletter BUSINESS MATTERS with the permission of CPA Canada. BUSINESS MATTERS is a bimonthly newsletter prepared by the CPA Canada for the clients of its members.

Disclaimer:

BUSINESS MATTERS deals with a number of complex issues in a concise manner; it is recommended that accounting, legal or other appropriate professional advice should be sought before acting upon any of the information contained therein.

Although every reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this letter, no individual or organization involved in either the preparation or distribution of this letter accepts any contractual, tortious, or any other form of liability for its contents or for any consequences arising from its use.

Richard Fulcher, CPA, CA – Author; Patricia Adamson, M.A., M.I.St. – CPA Canada Editor.

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Why is Bay Street soaring, while Main Street suffers?

Despite one million Canadians being out of work since the pandemic took hold and while small businesses struggle to pay the rent and stay in business, how is it that Canadian stocks almost broke even for 2020? The answer is “easy money.” Monetary authorities around the world, including the Bank of Canada, have cut interest…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Reverse Saving: Borrowing to Invest in the Stock Market

Legendary investor Benjamin Graham said that the investor’s chief problem and even their worst enemy is likely to be themselves. Indeed, borrowing to invest is not for the faint of heart. Why might you consider borrowing to invest in the stock market? Traditionally, discussions with your financial professional related to borrowing and investing occur at…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Cleaning out your financial closet under quarantine

Sheltering in place has been tough; not being able to meet with family or friends, nor being able to step outside your home for a break required us all to adjust. There were some positives to the lockdown, though, including finishing off home projects you’ve been putting off. Another “to-do” that you might want to…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Investment market update: What happened?

There was nowhere to hide in the first quarter of 2020 as the decade-long bull market in stocks came to a dramatic and sudden end in late February. With the novel coronavirus spreading rapidly around the world, economies are closed for business as stay-at-home orders were issued in Canada and abroad. What is being done…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Babies: The Cost and How to Plan for It

A reality of the economic and demographic trends occurring in Canada is that everything costs more, especially in urban centres. Take real estate costs, for instance, which for new parents might be eight to ten multiples of their combined income to acquire a detached home. For new or expecting parents, this is increasingly a key…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Things you need to know when it comes to U.S. taxes for individuals: General filing requirements

A U.S. filing requirement generally applies to individuals who are U.S. citizens, U.S. lawful permanent residents, and other individuals who earn income from U.S. sources. Do you fall into any of these categories? If yes, you’ll want to read this third article in our series on U.S. tax filing obligations. Filing requirements Many people are…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Federal government support related to COVID-19: Tax implications you can expect in 2020

The COVID-19 pandemic is imposing unprecedented strains on our economy and on our personal financial situations. The federal government continues to modify its programs that offer targeted support for individuals, businesses and other organizations. If you have received any of these benefits, there may be personal and corporate tax implications to you. Here is an update as…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Things You Need to Know When it Comes to U.S. Taxes For Individuals: Accidental Americans

It is becoming more well-known that United States citizens have income tax filing requirements from their home country, regardless of where they reside. However, there are some people who do not know they hold U.S. citizenship. Are you potentially one of these “accidental Americans”? Read on to learn more … What is an “accidental American”?…

· Business Matters, Management

Whole Life Harmony – The New Work-Life Balance

As we all seek out new and better norms, having experienced a global pandemic, one thing for sure is that the journey to get to where you want to go ought to feel as satisfying as possible. Consider becoming aware of and striving for whole life harmony – for when you are in harmony within yourself, you are in…

· Business Matters, Technology

Preserve Cybersecurity While Working Remotely

Most organizations have moved their workforces to some form of remote work as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Surprisingly, remote work has proven effective for many organizations, and they are now contemplating updating their remote work policies to allow employees more flexibility in a post-COVID-19 world. However, from a cybersecurity standpoint, remote work presents…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Update on COVID-19 federal government support

As was covered in the last issue, the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in unprecedented strains on our economy and our personal financial situations. The federal government announced several programs offering targeted support for individuals, businesses and other organizations. The following outlines the updates and amendments to these programs from May 13 to July 1. All individuals…