Client portal sign-in

Reverse Saving: Borrowing to Invest in the Stock Market

Business Matters, Wealth Management

Legendary investor Benjamin Graham said that the investor’s chief problem and even their worst enemy is likely to be themselves. Indeed, borrowing to invest is not for the faint of heart.

Why might you consider borrowing to invest in the stock market?

Traditionally, discussions with your financial professional related to borrowing and investing occur at the same time. This typically happens when the two following market conditions are present:

  1. Borrowing rates are low.
  2. Stocks are cheap after a dramatic decline in stock prices.

For instance, there was nowhere to hide in the first quarter of 2020: With the novel coronavirus spreading rapidly around the world, economies were closed for business as stay-at-home orders were issued in Canada and abroad. Stock markets and interest rates both fell dramatically, offering investors these traditional incentives to pursue a leveraged investment strategy.

Are you fit to borrow to invest?

These two key factors should dictate whether borrowing to invest is right for you:

  • your ability to take risk
  • your willingness to take risk 

To assess your ability to take risk, you would look to the factual details laid out in your financial strategy or retirement plan. If your retirement plan cannot sustain higher expected risk (in other words, your cash flow is tight), then this investment strategy is not something you should consider.

Borrowing to invest is a better strategy for investors who have excess cash flow and need help building long-term equity outside their principal residence and/or business. Those who typically might benefit from this strategy are professionals with their own practices, such as partners at law, accounting firms, doctors or dentists.

Next, consider your willingness to take risk. If you can’t sleep at night because your portfolio of investments using your own money has declined in value – never mind other people’s money that you are considering borrowing from the bank – then this strategy is not right for you. However, if you are among the investors who have survived previous “bear markets” (i.e., stocks declining 20% or more) and have not panicked, then this strategy is one for you to consider.

Another situation that favours this investment strategy is that Canadians are traditionally very good at paying down debt, but they may struggle with building equity through savings outside their registered RRSP and TFSA accounts. So, this leveraged strategy of borrowing to invest could make sense – it forces the investor to save while they focus on paying down debt, which they have historical experience doing aggressively.

Your leveraged investment plan: A double-edged sword

Whether you acquire real estate with a mortgage or a stock portfolio using borrowed funds, the returns on those investments are magnified by the use of leverage and the cost of borrowing. As a result, you will see an enhanced and asymmetric impact on returns – the returns swing up and down.

In plain language, this means that if your portfolio (half borrowed and half not borrowed money or “equity”) earned or lost 10% in a given year, the impact on the equity within your portfolio will move up and down by 17% and 23% (this is a highly simplistic example that assumes a 3% per annum cost to borrow). You can see that although the portfolio returns were symmetric – both up and down 10% – the equity return is asymmetric: it is higher and lower than the portfolio return, and it increases and declines by unequal amounts.

The enhanced equity returns up and down are caused by the use of leverage, while the asymmetry in returns is caused by the cost of borrowing. This asymmetry in returns creates the added need to get the timing right on your leveraged investment strategy. If you implement the leveraged investment strategy and your portfolio declines in value, stress and emotion can kick in and derail even the most seasoned investor’s plan, resulting in a bad outcome overall.

Keep your leveraged investment plan clean and tax deductible

Borrowing to invest is tax-deductible in Canada when money is invested in a non-registered account. To keep your cost of investing clear for the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), set up a line of credit dedicated only to your leveraged investment strategy. That way, it will be crystal clear how much it cost you to invest.

Success is based on diversification

Although we like to believe we can predict the future, we must accept that uncertainty is a part of the investing process, so with this realization you should spread out your investment risk to accommodate various scenarios. One way to achieve this is by owning stocks in different sectors that are thus exposed to different economic influences.

A common idea behind this leveraged strategy is to cover your cost of borrowing by purchasing dividend-paying stocks. You can find dividend-paying securities in almost all sectors of the economy, not just in the long-established Canadian banking sector.

Another way to diversify is to look at your portfolio in a North American context, and not just focus on Canadian stocks. Although you can realize tax advantages to owning Canadian dividend stocks through the dividend tax credit, tax considerations should be secondary in your mind to enhanced diversification.

Canadians who invest a portion of their leveraged strategy in the United States are likely to find many more stocks in a wider range of sectors of the economy (technology, health care, consumer discretionary, etc.), which can enhance your portfolio’s diversification and outcomes. In addition, exposure to the U.S. greenback has historically provided Canadian investors with an enhanced source of diversification against market uncertainty.

The golden rule

Ignoring all the factors already discussed, the golden rule for anyone contemplating borrowing to invest is to look at the worst-case scenario.

Consider what would happen if your leveraged investment strategy went to zero and you still owed the bank the loan and interest. If this scenario would impair your family’s current and expected lifestyle, then you should reconsider this strategy. Because, in essence, this strategy should be viewed as being more aspirational: We are trying to achieve the lifestyle we want in future, but not by losing the foundation (our needs) we have at present.

This article is reprinted from the newsletter BUSINESS MATTERS with the permission of CPA Canada. BUSINESS MATTERS is a bimonthly newsletter prepared by the CPA Canada for the clients of its members.

Disclaimer:

BUSINESS MATTERS deals with a number of complex issues in a concise manner; it is recommended that accounting, legal or other appropriate professional advice should be sought before acting upon any of the information contained therein.

Although every reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this letter, no individual or organization involved in either the preparation or distribution of this letter accepts any contractual, tortious, or any other form of liability for its contents or for any consequences arising from its use.

Richard Fulcher, CPA, CA – Author; Patricia Adamson, M.A., M.I.St. – CPA Canada Editor.

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Why is Bay Street soaring, while Main Street suffers?

Despite one million Canadians being out of work since the pandemic took hold and while small businesses struggle to pay the rent and stay in business, how is it that Canadian stocks almost broke even for 2020? The answer is “easy money.” Monetary authorities around the world, including the Bank of Canada, have cut interest…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

GIC versus GIC … What’s the difference? Time and money!

Confused? You would not be the first person to mix up these two GIC investment vehicles: guaranteed investment certificates and guaranteed interest contracts. Although their acronym is the same, the differences between these GICs could have material implications for your money, especially when it comes to transferring wealth to the next generation. Individuals often find…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Cleaning out your financial closet under quarantine

Sheltering in place has been tough; not being able to meet with family or friends, nor being able to step outside your home for a break required us all to adjust. There were some positives to the lockdown, though, including finishing off home projects you’ve been putting off. Another “to-do” that you might want to…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Investment market update: What happened?

There was nowhere to hide in the first quarter of 2020 as the decade-long bull market in stocks came to a dramatic and sudden end in late February. With the novel coronavirus spreading rapidly around the world, economies are closed for business as stay-at-home orders were issued in Canada and abroad. What is being done…

· Business Matters, Wealth Management

Babies: The Cost and How to Plan for It

A reality of the economic and demographic trends occurring in Canada is that everything costs more, especially in urban centres. Take real estate costs, for instance, which for new parents might be eight to ten multiples of their combined income to acquire a detached home. For new or expecting parents, this is increasingly a key…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Things you need to know when it comes to U.S. taxes for individuals: General filing requirements

A U.S. filing requirement generally applies to individuals who are U.S. citizens, U.S. lawful permanent residents, and other individuals who earn income from U.S. sources. Do you fall into any of these categories? If yes, you’ll want to read this third article in our series on U.S. tax filing obligations. Filing requirements Many people are…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Federal government support related to COVID-19: Tax implications you can expect in 2020

The COVID-19 pandemic is imposing unprecedented strains on our economy and on our personal financial situations. The federal government continues to modify its programs that offer targeted support for individuals, businesses and other organizations. If you have received any of these benefits, there may be personal and corporate tax implications to you. Here is an update as…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Things You Need to Know When it Comes to U.S. Taxes For Individuals: Accidental Americans

It is becoming more well-known that United States citizens have income tax filing requirements from their home country, regardless of where they reside. However, there are some people who do not know they hold U.S. citizenship. Are you potentially one of these “accidental Americans”? Read on to learn more … What is an “accidental American”?…

· Business Matters, Management

Whole Life Harmony – The New Work-Life Balance

As we all seek out new and better norms, having experienced a global pandemic, one thing for sure is that the journey to get to where you want to go ought to feel as satisfying as possible. Consider becoming aware of and striving for whole life harmony – for when you are in harmony within yourself, you are in…

· Business Matters, Technology

Preserve Cybersecurity While Working Remotely

Most organizations have moved their workforces to some form of remote work as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Surprisingly, remote work has proven effective for many organizations, and they are now contemplating updating their remote work policies to allow employees more flexibility in a post-COVID-19 world. However, from a cybersecurity standpoint, remote work presents…

· Business Matters, Taxation

Update on COVID-19 federal government support

As was covered in the last issue, the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in unprecedented strains on our economy and our personal financial situations. The federal government announced several programs offering targeted support for individuals, businesses and other organizations. The following outlines the updates and amendments to these programs from May 13 to July 1. All individuals…